‘Trumpian’: Zali Steggall on Morrison’s many hats
Paul Karp
The independent MP for Warringah, Zali Steggall, has said she is “very concerned by the lack of accountability and transparency” in Scott Morrison’s decision to be appointed to extra portfolios including finance, resources and health.
Steggall told Guardian Australia that Morrison’s “spin” in describing the move as a safety check in pandemic times “doesn’t explain the secrecy”.
Steggall wants more information on the attorney general’s role, whether solicitor general’s advice was obtained and the governor-general’s “involvement” in the decision not to make the appointments public.
She said:
It seems to be part of a Trumpian desire to turn the prime minister into a presidency, where the PM would gain ultimate say on decisions and the ability to override ministers.
Steggall noted Anthony Albanese has referred the matter for investigation, but suggested the question of whether it should be referred to parliament’s privileges committee is “live” – it “needs to be looked at”.
Steggall said she is concerned by the potential local impact, because the proponent of the Pep11 gas development is challenging the validity of the rejection in court, and “the secrecy may advance an argument for the company challenging the decision”. She would be “incredibly annoyed” if Morrison’s role helped the company get the decision overturned.
Key events
Hobart council to remove divisive statue of former premier
A contentious statue of a former Tasmanian premier who mutilated the body of an Aboriginal man in 1869 will be taken down by the Hobart City Council.
William Crowther, a surgeon and politician, stole the skull of William Lanne from a morgue and sent it to the Royal College of Surgeons in London.
Crowther was suspended from a position at the Hobart General Hospital as a result. He became premier briefly nine years later.
Hobart City Council on Monday night voted 7-4 to remove the statue from Franklin Square in the capital’s CBD after years of campaigning from Aboriginal groups.
Lord mayor Anna Reynolds described it as a practical and meaningful step to reconciliation and one part of a broader national conversation. She told the meeting:
(This) does not change history. The records, the books, the articles, the stories all remain unchanged .
We don’t want to celebrate a time in our history when scientists and doctors wanted to prove theories of European superiority (and) wanted to rank people by their race.
It was an appalling tradition.
Reynolds said the statue would be conserved and potentially reinterpreted. The meeting was told preliminary discussions had been held with the Tasmanian Museum and Art Gallery.
– via AAP
Peter Hannam
Tasmanian electricity interconnector ceases imports
Tasmania is usually blessed with an abundance of electricity given its hydro resources in particular but also its Basslink with the mainland to fill any short term gap.
May not be a big deal but Basslink (in receivership since last November) apparently ceased imports this morning (just before 6am AEST and that remains the case).
Without those imports, spot wholesale electricity prices in the NEM were notably higher recently (though the gap has now closed) than the mainland states.
The power interruption, if that’s what it is (we’ve asked), makes it worthwhile to look at the state of Tasmania’s hydro resources. The climate drivers (mostly La Nina and a negative Indian Ocean Dipole) that have been pushing extra moisture into much of eastern Australia have not been benefitting western Tasmania.
One consequence is the biggest dam in the Hydro Tasmanian system is well below full levels, prompting the state-run company last week to note “the total energy in storage dropped below the Prudent Storage Level” briefly.
As our colleague Adam Morton noted in 2016 (in a different role), drought and Basslink woes prompted the Tassie government to resort to cloudseeding and diesel generators to keep the lights on.
A very long way off that, of course, but a reminder of the complexity (and vulnerability) of our energy supplies.
Victoria records 20 Covid deaths
Victoria has recorded 20 Covid deaths and 4,858 new cases in the latest reporting period, with 535 people in hospital and 25 in intensive care.
NSW records 24 Covid deaths
New South Wales has recorded 24 Covid deaths and 7,145 new cases in the latest reporting period, with 2,141 people in hospital and 60 people in intensive care.
‘Our democracy, frankly, deserve better’: Albanese on Morrison’s secret powers
The prime minister Anthony Albanese followed his ABC Radio interview with another on ABC Melbourne, which came hot on the heels of Scott Morrison’s air time on 2GB.
Virginia Trioli asked Albanese about Morrison’s response saying the arrangements were fine as, quote, “The buck stops with me as prime minister”.
Albanese said Morrison was not right “because on issues like resources, that the buck actually stops with the resources minister under legislation to make particular decisions”.
We don’t have a one-person band here. What we have is a government that has inbuilt checks and balances. And that’s why this is such a breach of convention. It’s a breach of processes. And it is typical of someone who, of course, set up a cabinet committee of one so that he could have meetings with various people and say that it was a meeting of that subcommittee of the cabinet.
It would appear that the former government went out of its way to hide information and to be to have a lack of transparency. No wonder they objected to having a national anti-corruption commission. This went to the very nature in the heart of the Coalition government that governed for a period of time and simply lost any perspective about accountability to the Australian people on the way through, that operated in the shadows. And Australians deserve better. And our democracy, frankly, deserve better as well.
Trioli also asked Albanese about the reports that also came through during the ABC Melbourne interview that Morrison was also secretly sworn into the social services portfolio.
Albanese said he was not aware “of that particular detail”. He said he would be receiving a briefing this morning and will “have more to say later this morning.”
‘Trumpian’: Zali Steggall on Morrison’s many hats
Paul Karp
The independent MP for Warringah, Zali Steggall, has said she is “very concerned by the lack of accountability and transparency” in Scott Morrison’s decision to be appointed to extra portfolios including finance, resources and health.
Steggall told Guardian Australia that Morrison’s “spin” in describing the move as a safety check in pandemic times “doesn’t explain the secrecy”.
Steggall wants more information on the attorney general’s role, whether solicitor general’s advice was obtained and the governor-general’s “involvement” in the decision not to make the appointments public.
She said:
It seems to be part of a Trumpian desire to turn the prime minister into a presidency, where the PM would gain ultimate say on decisions and the ability to override ministers.
Steggall noted Anthony Albanese has referred the matter for investigation, but suggested the question of whether it should be referred to parliament’s privileges committee is “live” – it “needs to be looked at”.
Steggall said she is concerned by the potential local impact, because the proponent of the Pep11 gas development is challenging the validity of the rejection in court, and “the secrecy may advance an argument for the company challenging the decision”. She would be “incredibly annoyed” if Morrison’s role helped the company get the decision overturned.
Josh Butler
What does the revelation of Morrison being sworn into a fourth ministry mean?
AAP earlier reported that Scott Morrison had himself sworn into the social services portfolio last year. Morrison has disputed this, saying he had no recollection of that, in his 2GB interview earlier. Let’s go through this.
An administrative arrangements order, dated 28 June 2021 and signed by both Morrison and the governor general David Hurley, sets out a small number of changes of responsibility among ministers. On that document, it notes that the prime minister had taken over administration of the “Social Security Act 1991, insofar as it relates to Australian Government Disaster Recovery Payment and the Disaster Recovery Allowance”, and the “Social Security (Administration) Act 1999, insofar as it relates to Australian Government Disaster Recovery Payment and the Disaster Recovery Allowance”.
The AAO shows that those powers were actually held by the home affairs minister previously – not the social services minister. The document also specifically says the social services minister has power over most of the Social Services Acts. The document doesn’t exactly prove that Morrison took on social services minister roles, just that he was given administration of one part of that portfolio’s legislation, which was actually previously a power of the home affairs minister.
Morrison told 2GB that he didn’t recall being sworn in as social services minister, but that he was “pursuing” such questions: “I’m happy if there are other (portfolios) to be out there.”
In an ABC Melbourne interview, the PM Anthony Albanese said he too was not aware of Morrison taking on social services, but flagged: “I’ll be receiving a briefing this morning shortly. And I’ll have more to say later this morning.”
Queensland government to unveil path to Indigenous treaty
Indigenous people will be able to give evidence about injustices committed against them in Queensland as part of the state’s plans to sign a treaty with the state’s First Nations population, AAP reports.
The premier Annastacia Palaszczuk will announce today that an Indigenous truth-telling and healing inquiry will be set up in response to the treaty advancement committee’s final report.
Palaszczuk says laws will also be passed to set up a First Nations Institute within 18 months to draft a legal framework for treaty negotiations. She said in a statement:
What we do next on the Path to Treaty will define our humanity, our sense of fairness, and the legacy we leave our children,
Treaty is about finding a place where we can face up to our shared history and be truthful about all of it – good and bad – and build a future together where we value, trust, and respect each other.
A Path to Treaty office will be set up within government to prepare for treaty talks once a legal framework has been drafted.
An independent interim body with Indigenous and non-Indigenous representatives will be appointed to oversee the treaty process until the First Nations Institute is established.
The body will lead local truth-telling initiatives to “promote a shared understanding” of history in institutions such as public libraries, museums, archives and art galleries.
Queensland could become the fourth jurisdiction to sign a treaty with Indigenous peoples. Victoria and the ACT have already done so, while the Northern Territory is in an advanced stage of its own treaty process.
McKenzie joins calls for explanation over Morrison secret appointments
Nationals senator Bridget McKenzie, the shadow infrastructure minister, is on Sky News joining her party leader David Littleproud in saying Australians deserve an explanation for Morrison’s secret ministerial appointments.
There needs to be an explanation.
McKenzie said that Australians understand Morrison assuming the health minister’s responsibility, which needed additional oversight during the pandemic. But she says when it comes to the finance and resources portfolios it is not clear what Morrison’s motivation was:
If it’s just for political reasons, it’s a disgrace.
Morrison defends appointment to health and finance portfolios, saying he didn’t use powers
Circling back to Morrison’s interview on 2GB – he defended not making public his assumption of the health and finance portfolios because he did not use the powers.
We had to take some extraordinary measures to put safeguards in place … None of these in the case of the finance and the health portfolio ever required – were required to be used – and they were there as a safeguard. They were there as a redundancy because both of the powers, the powers in those portfolios, they weren’t overseen by cabinet. So, the minister himself and, in both cases, had powers that few if any minister in our federation history was having.
He did not explain as explicitly whether he exercised the powers as the resources minister. As we’re reported, Morrison used the extraordinary powers to overrule the resources minister and block the Pep11 gas exploration licence off the coast of NSW.
Woman arrested for allegedly stabbing her two children in Adelaide
A 35-year-old woman has been arrested after allegedly stabbing her two children in a car on a motorway in Adelaide late last night.
South Australian Police have released a statement:
Just before 11.30pm on Monday 15 August, police were called to the North South Motorway at Wingfield after a member of the public phoned to advise a woman had been detained.
Police will allege that the woman stopped her car and removed her two young children before stabbing them with a knife.
A member of the public stopped his car on the motorway and intervened, disarming the woman. Soon after he was assisted by other members of the public who restrained the woman until police arrived.
The two young children from Modbury Heights, were taken to the Women’s and Children’s Hospital by SAAS where they were treated for critical injuries. They remain in hospital in a stable condition.
The woman, a 35-year-old from Modbury Heights, was arrested and taken to Royal Adelaide Hospital where she has been detained and will likely be charged with two counts of attempted murder.
Benita Kolovos
Victorian government to introduce bill in response to Lawyer X inquiry
People who expose the identity of police informants may face 10 years’ jail under a bill to be introduced to Victoria’s parliament in response to the Lawyer X royal commission.
The state’s attorney general, Jaclyn Symes, announced the Human Source Management Bill 2022 will be introduced to parliament on Tuesday to deliver on 25 of the recommendations from the royal commission.
The inquiry was called in 2018 after it emerged that the former defence barrister Nicola Gobbo had been acting as a police informant against her own clients and other high-profile mafia figures.
The bill is the first of its kind in Australia and sets out the process for the registration, use and management of Victoria police informants and establishes an external oversight model to ensure they are used in an ethical and justifiable manner.
Under the reforms, Victoria police will have to apply to a senior officer to register a person as an informant. The senior officer will only approve the registration if it is appropriate and justified.
Protections will be put in place where the risks are greatest – such as when a person has access to privileged information, is under 18 or has a serious physical or mental health condition.
The bill makes it an offence to disclose information that would reveal a person is or was an informant unless the disclosure is for a permitted purpose, with a maximum penalty of two years’ jails.
It also includes an aggravated offence where a person who discloses the information does so to either endanger the health or safety of any person, or interfere with a criminal investigation or prosecution. The maximum penalty for this offence is 10 years’ jail.
The Public Interest Monitor office will oversee all registrations of high-risk informants and the Independent Broad-based Anti-Corruption Commission will monitor Victoria Police’s compliance with the scheme.
If passed, 48 of the 55 recommendations to government would have been acted upon since the royal commission handed down its findings last year.
Symes says work is well underway to deliver the remaining recommendations:
Human sources are extremely valuable for police but we need clear laws in place to appropriately manage the inherent risks that go with it for both the person involved and Victoria Police.
These important and nation-leading reforms achieve the appropriate balance between mitigating the risks of using human sources and ensuring Victoria Police can continue to act on information to keep our community safe.
Morrison also sworn in to social services portfolio – report
Scott Morrison was sworn into a fourth portfolio, with documents revealing more about the former prime minister’s moves to secretly install himself across his government’s ministries, AAP reports.
An administrative arrangements order for the social services portfolio was signed by Morrison and the governor general David Hurley on 28 June 2021, on top of him also being privately sworn in as health minister, finance minister and resources minister.
‘I think it was the right decision’: Morrison defends taking over resources portfolio
Morrison was asked about his involvement in decisions around the resources portfolio on 2GB earlier this morning.
As my colleagues Sarah Martin and Lisa Cox report:
Morrison’s decision to use extraordinary ministerial powers to block the controversial Pep11 gas exploration licence off the coast of NSW is being challenged in the federal court, with the proponent accusing the former prime minister of “bias” that denied procedural fairness.
Morrison responded on 2GB that the resources portfolio had a “specific set of circumstances”.
He maintains:
I think it was the right decision.
Morrison apologises to Mathias Cormann, admitting error
Mathias Cormann, the former finance minister, was not aware that Morrison had given himself the powers of the finance minister and only learned about the alleged assumption of powers this week.
On that, Morrsion told 2GB:
That was an error … I’ve apologised to Mathias for that.
I thought matter had been sorted between offices.